A new pattern is not yet a new learning problem
A different passing order can remain the same exercise. Meaningful variation changes what players perceive, decide and do.
Field and indoor practice research
More exercises do not automatically mean more variety. We compare publicly available federation coaching material, examine what players actually have to solve and use that to design better practices.
01 · Method
We read practical descriptions and manuals from KNHB, Hockey Australia, FIH and SA Hockey. Public information from England, New Zealand, Canada, Germany and Ireland helps compare approaches. An index or course page does not count as a reviewed exercise library.
For each form we compare objectives, roles, space, opposition, scoring, transitions, rotation and coaching questions. We distinguish an exercise, a harder version and an entire session. Foreign age labels do not automatically become Dutch age thresholds.
This is exploratory source and design research. The examples below are not newly approved library exercises. No effectiveness study or independent field validation has been carried out. We do not use restricted exercise libraries.
02 · Findings
A different passing order can remain the same exercise. Meaningful variation changes what players perceive, decide and do.
Zones, multiple targets, changing overloads and clear release cues create different problems. The animation must show that difference.
A measurable skill challenge has a different purpose from a game with decisions after losing possession. A varied library needs both.
Floor, boards, passing angles and pressure change decisions. Adding boards around an outdoor practice does not make it a good indoor practice.
These are our design conclusions, not a ranking of proven best drills. The source examples make the differences concrete.
03 · Practice families
Brief analyses of public material. No reproduced diagrams or complete drill descriptions.
12 reviewed practice families
One player always supports the team in possession.
Design implication: Show the changing role and every target, rather than just a circulating pass.
Source: KNHB [1]
A corridor determines when a pass can cross.
Design implication: Draw the zones and show an unsuccessful crossing too.
Source: KNHB [2]
A regain changes both direction and scoring method.
Design implication: The animation needs two meaningful outcomes.
Source: KNHB [3]
An occupancy rule prevents finishers from waiting in their zone.
Design implication: Make the zone and arrival timing visible.
Source: KNHB [4]
The reception determines when defenders may start.
Design implication: Distinguish waiting and active players and show the release cue.
Source: KNHB [5]
A ball-exclusion zone changes where the duel can happen.
Design implication: Technique has a recognisable tactical consequence.
Source: KNHB [6]
A call determines who enters the next situation.
Design implication: Show entry, exit and short waiting time.
Source: Hockey Australia [7]
Assigned zones make players find connections.
Design implication: The spatial restriction must change the game.
Source: Hockey Australia [7]
A time or accuracy score makes progress visible.
Design implication: Explain what is measured; an animation does not demonstrate skill.
Source: FIH Academy [8]
The receiving direction changes the preparation required.
Design implication: Design a real indoor setup with suitable foot and stick positioning.
Source: FIH [10]
The pressure position determines whether the board route is useful.
Design implication: A board is an option with a reason, not a decorative edge.
Source: FIH [17]
04 · Design
What is not working in the game, and which decision should the practice invite?
Targets, zones, direction and distances must support the learning objective.
Specify active players, waiting players, goalkeepers, neutrals and rotations.
Describe scoring, loss, regain, out-of-play and restart.
Name observable behaviour specific to this problem.
Change the decision or opposition, rather than automatically changing only size.
Show the defining situation, including an alternative or failure.
Distinguish an original design, an adaptation and a background reference.
First we develop a small, clearly varied series. Delivery, animation and field review follow. The number follows meaningful coverage; a harder variation does not automatically count as another exercise.
05 · Sources & rights
All sources below were publicly consulted on the stated review date.
We retain original titles, creators, publishers and locations. We write our own summaries and link to the source. We have not established a general open reuse licence for this material and do not reproduce source images, videos or complete drills.
For adaptation or reproduction we assess the specific licence or permission separately, including translation and onward sharing. Attribution is not permission or federation endorsement. The status below records our check, not a full legal assessment.
KNHB · Netherlands · Practice material
KNHB · Wedstrijdvorm
A neutral player changes allegiance with possession; multiple targets create a decision.
Source restricts reuse. Rights reference
KNHB · Netherlands · Practice material
KNHB · Spelvorm: twee vakken met een tussenruimte
Separate playing zones and an interception corridor change the passing decision.
Source restricts reuse. Rights reference
KNHB · Netherlands · Practice material
KNHB · Wedstrijdvorm
Teams have different targets: a large goal against two exits.
Source restricts reuse. Rights reference
KNHB · Netherlands · Practice material
KNHB · Wedstrijdvorm en bijbehorende spelvorm
A defined baseline zone and occupancy rule make timing essential.
Source restricts reuse. Rights reference
KNHB · Netherlands · Practice material
KNHB · Eerste wedstrijdvorm
A deep reception triggers pursuing pressure.
Source restricts reuse. Rights reference
KNHB · Netherlands · Practice material
KNHB · Wedstrijdvorm
A ball-exclusion zone and different scoring methods give the defensive duel context.
Source restricts reuse. Rights reference
Hockey Australia · Australia · Manual
Hockey Australia · pp. 10, 17, 61–62
A junior guide with game cards, coaching questions and levels, including Number Hockey and Zone Hockey.
No open reuse licence established.
FIH Academy · International · Practice material
FIH Academy · Challenges 1–5
Five technical challenges with measurable scores and three levels; a different practice type from a game.
No open reuse licence established.
FIH · International · Framework
FIH · Indoor receiving; playing the boards
Indoor coaching has dedicated receiving and board-play resources. Not every illustrated combination fits a single-ball animation.
Copyright notice; no open reuse licence established. Rights reference
FIH · International · Practice material
FIH · PDF pp. 1–3
Original indoor diagrams with different passing directions, organisations and receiving situations.
Copyright notice; no open reuse licence established. Rights reference
South African Hockey Association & KNHB · South Africa · Manual
SAHA & KNHB; Frank Dikmoet, Gabrielle van Doorn, Gary Dolley, Jenny King, Thom Terwee (contributors) · pp. 1, 8–9 (PDF 2, 9–10)
Connects organisation, purposeful progression and technical observation. Historical teaching material, not current Dutch rules.
No open reuse licence established.
England Hockey · England · Framework
England Hockey · Small sided hockey
Small-sided games are a distinct format; numbers, targets and goalkeeper use follow the participants.
Source restricts reuse. Rights reference
Canterbury Hockey · New Zealand · Framework
Canterbury Hockey · pp. 1–2
A regional Small Sticks implementation: development, participation and role rotation. Rules are specific to its date and location.
No open reuse licence established.
Field Hockey Canada · Canada · Public resource index
Field Hockey Canada · Coaching; Planning
Public entry point for game-based learning and session planning. A listed download is not proof that every file was reviewed.
No open reuse licence established.
Deutscher Hockey-Bund · Germany · Public resource index
Deutscher Hockey-Bund · Public training guidance
Only the public explanation was used. The subscription-based exercise library is outside this review.
No open reuse licence established.
Hockey Ireland · Ireland · Framework
Hockey Ireland · Coaching pathway
Describes technical and tactical learning through small games; no exercise library was copied.
No open reuse licence established.
FIH · International · Practice material
Heino Knuf · German Coaching Committee · I–III; FIH 1. Indoor Coaching Course
Practices connect board use to receiving direction, movement and opposition. The board route is not always the best option.
Copyright notice; no open reuse licence established. Rights reference